Hamilton Khaki Aviation Pilot PioneervsGarrick S2 Deadbeat Seconds

Owners widely praise the Hamilton Khaki Aviation Pilot Pioneer for its authentic pilot design, legible cathedral hands, and textured matte black dial, with the 36mm and 38mm case sizes noted as wearing well. The applied numerals with generous Super Luminova are a highlight, and one owner found the double AR-coated mineral crystal surprisingly scratch-free. However, the lume is not very bright or long-lasting, and the mechanical version requires about 60 crown turns to fully wind. Some owners find the rotating bezel's detents unremarkable, and the mineral crystal can scratch more easily than sapphire, though this is considered a minor drawback given the price. On balance, owners rate the Hamilton Khaki Aviation Pilot Pioneer highly for its vintage appeal and quality build at the price point.

The Garrick S2 Deadbeat Seconds is praised for its handcrafted dial and in-house DB-G06 movement featuring a deadbeat seconds complication. Reviewers note the movement is regulated to within +3 seconds per day and offers a 45-hour power reserve, with traditional decoration and a large balance bridge. The 42mm stainless steel case is 10mm thick and boasts 100m water resistance. A significant drawback is the substantial wait time, ranging from at least a year to 16 months, and the watch is priced at £19,000 before taxes, with only 10 produced annually. Overall, reviewers highlight the Garrick S2 Deadbeat Seconds as a highly personalized and handcrafted timepiece, with the long lead time being the primary consideration.