Side by side

Melbourne Watch Company CarltonvsSheffield 1A

The numbers, the dial colors, the calibers — laid out so you can stop flipping between tabs.

Add a watch
Carlton
Melbourne Watch CompanyCarlton
MSRP $294
1A
Sheffield1A
MSRP $223
Buy from Melbourne Watch Company ↗
Buy used on eBay ↗
Buy from Sheffield ↗
Buy used on eBay ↗

At a glance

11 of 29 specs differ
Diameter
Carlton42mm
1A40mm
Power Reserve
Carlton—
1A—
Water Resistance
Carlton50m
1A200m
MSRP
Carlton$294
1A$223

Full specifications

Case

6 specs
Category
—
Diver
Diameter
42mm
40mm
Thickness
11mm
12.8mm
Lug-to-Lug
—
46mm
Lug Width
22mm
20mm
Water Resistance
50m
200m

Crystal & Dial

2 specs
Dial Color
Black
White/Blue
Lume
None
Swiss blue lume

Movement

2 specs
Caliber
Ronda Cal. 5021D
Seiko NH35A
Type
Quartz
Automatic

Pricing

1 specs
MSRP
—
$223
Keep exploring

More watches worth a look

Matched to the watches above on size, movement, style and price — microbrands first. Open any one to dig in.

Spinnaker Hull Chronograph
Spinnakermicro

Hull Chronograph

8 watches · 32 variantsHull
42mm·Quartz·100m WR
$149MSRP
—Used
Boldr The T Rex By Boldr X Nitecore
Boldrmicro

The T Rex By Boldr X Nitecore

Ref. the-t-rex-by-boldr-x-nitecore
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
$499MSRP
—Used
Omologato Panamericana Chrono
Omologatomicro

Panamericana Chrono

2 variantsRef.
41mm·Mecaquartz
$604MSRP
—Used
Sheffield SCR
Sheffieldmicro

SCR

2 variantsRef. scr-grun
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
—MSRP
—Used
Sunrex Anemone City
Sunrexmicro
Banana Reef

Anemone City

2 variantsRef.
40mm·Solar·100m WR
$530MSRP
—Used
Boldr BOLDR x Nitecore
Boldrmicro
Limited Editions

BOLDR x Nitecore

Ref. boldr-x-nitecore-kraken
38mm·Automatic·200m WR
$449MSRP
—Used
Caught Watches Aeris
Caught Watchesmicro

Aeris

6 variantsRef. aeris-black-dial-men-watch
40mm·Mecaquartz
$261MSRP
—Used
Islander Islander Bayport Automatic Dive Watch with Blue Wave Dial #ISL-311
Islandermicro
Under $50

Islander Bayport Automatic Dive Watch with Blue Wave Dial #ISL-311

9 watches · 9 variantsUnder $50
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
$399MSRP
—Used
All alternatives to the Carlton →All alternatives to the 1A →
Explore the full catalog

Follow this matchup

Get a note when Melbourne Watch Company Carlton vs Sheffield 1A gets more votes, a community discussion, or a price drop. No account needed.

Adjacent matchups

People also compared

Comparisons nearby in the catalog — alternatives to the watches above paired against the matchup.

Sheffield 1AvsSpinnaker Hull ChronographOmologato Panamericana ChronovsSheffield 1ASheffield 1AvsSunrex Anemone CityCaught Watches AerisvsSheffield 1AMelbourne Watch Company CarltonvsSheffield 1A diver ~40mm 3-hand, Arabic numerals (12/3/6/9), no dateMelbourne Watch Company CarltonvsBoldr The T Rex By Boldr X Nitecore
Edit this comparisonAdd another watchExplore more 39–43mm watches