Side by side

Cincinnati Watch Company PhantomvsTudor Black Bay 54

The numbers, the dial colors, the calibers — laid out so you can stop flipping between tabs.

Add a watch
Phantom
Cincinnati Watch CompanyPhantom
MSRP $1,995
Black Bay 54
TudorBlack Bay 54
MSRP $4,725
Buy from Cincinnati Watch Company ↗
Buy used on eBay ↗
Buy from Tudor ↗
Buy used on eBay ↗

At a glance

20 of 29 specs differ
Diameter
Phantom38mm
Black Bay 5437mm
Power Reserve
Phantom45h
Black Bay 5470h
Water Resistance
Phantom100m
Black Bay 54200m
MSRP
Phantom$1,995
Black Bay 54$4,725

Full specifications

Case

8 specs
Category
Dress
Diver
Diameter
38mm
37mm
Thickness
10.2mm
11.2mm
Lug-to-Lug
46.5mm
46mm
Material
316L Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel
Finish
—
Polished + Satin
Water Resistance
100m
200m
Caseback
—
Solid screw-down

Crystal & Dial

5 specs
Crystal Shape
Domed
—
AR Coating
Underside
—
Dial Color
Silver
Blue
Indices
—
Applied
Lume
None
Super-LumiNova

Movement

6 specs
Caliber
Sellita SW210-1
MT5400
Type
Manual
Automatic
Power Reserve
45h
70h
Jewels
18
0
Hacking
Yes
No
Hand-winding
Yes
No

Pricing

1 specs
MSRP
$1,995
$4,725
Keep exploring

More watches worth a look

Matched to the watches above on size, movement, style and price — microbrands first. Open any one to dig in.

Cincinnati Watch Company Rising Star
Cincinnati Watch Companymicro

Rising Star

Ref. rising-star
38mm·Manual·100m WR
$1,995MSRP
—Used
Islander Islander Northport 37mm Automatic Watch with Purple Ripple Dial #ISL-291
Islandermicro
Under $50

Islander Northport 37mm Automatic Watch with Purple Ripple Dial #ISL-291

9 watches · 9 variantsUnder $50
37mm·Automatic·200m WR
$499MSRP
—Used
Cincinnati Watch Company Tree Frog
Cincinnati Watch Companymicro

Tree Frog

Ref. tree-frog
38mm·Manual·100m WR
$1,995MSRP
—Used
Baltic Aquascaphe MK2
Balticmicro

Aquascaphe MK2

4 variantsAquascaphe MK2
37mm·Automatic·200m WR
$680MSRP
—Used
KUOE SOMBRERO 90-011
KUOEmicro

SOMBRERO 90-011

5 variantsSombrero
38mm·Automatic·200m WR
$980MSRP
—Used
anOrdain Model 1 (Group Buy)
anOrdainmicro

Model 1 (Group Buy)

2 watches · 2 variantsModel 1 (Group Buy)
38mm·Manual
$1,905MSRP
—Used
Venezianico Nereide Aureo 39
Venezianicomicro

Nereide Aureo 39

Ref. nereide-aureo-39-3121590s
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$1,000MSRP
—Used
anOrdain Model 1
anOrdainmicro
Model 2

Model 1

3 watches · 11 variantsModel 2
38mm·Manual
$1,334MSRP
—Used
All alternatives to the Phantom →All alternatives to the Black Bay 54 →
Explore the full catalog

Follow this matchup

Get a note when Cincinnati Watch Company Phantom vs Tudor Black Bay 54 gets more votes, a community discussion, or a price drop. No account needed.

Adjacent matchups

People also compared

Comparisons nearby in the catalog — alternatives to the watches above paired against the matchup.

Cincinnati Watch Company Rising StarvsTudor Black Bay 54Cincinnati Watch Company Tree FrogvsTudor Black Bay 54Tudor Black Bay 54vsCincinnati Watch Company When Pigs FlyanOrdain Model 1 (Group Buy)vsTudor Black Bay 54Islander Northport 37mm Automatic Watch with Purple Ripple Dial #ISL-291vsCincinnati Watch Company PhantomBaltic Aquascaphe MK2vsCincinnati Watch Company Phantom
Edit this comparisonAdd another watchExplore more 36–39mm watches