Garrick S2 Deadbeat SecondsvsZenith Defy Skyline Chronograph

The Garrick S2 Deadbeat Seconds is praised for its handcrafted dial and in-house DB-G06 movement featuring a deadbeat seconds complication. Reviewers note the movement is regulated to within +3 seconds per day and offers a 45-hour power reserve, with traditional decoration and a large balance bridge. The 42mm stainless steel case is 10mm thick and boasts 100m water resistance. A significant drawback is the substantial wait time, ranging from at least a year to 16 months, and the watch is priced at £19,000 before taxes, with only 10 produced annually. Overall, reviewers highlight the Garrick S2 Deadbeat Seconds as a highly personalized and handcrafted timepiece, with the long lead time being the primary consideration.

Owners widely praise the Zenith Defy Skyline Chronograph for its excellent finishing, integrated-bracelet design, and comfortable wearability, with some specifically noting its 100m water resistance and 42mm case size are well-executed. The dial's starry pattern and light reflection are frequently highlighted as attractive features, and the 1/10th-second indicator is seen by some as a cool complication. However, opinions are divided on the dial's finishing, with some finding the star pattern's interruption around other elements amateurish, and the 1/10th-second subdial is considered by some reviewers to render the running seconds useless. Some owners find the bracelet's first link rigid and the watch's lug-to-lug distance challenging for smaller or flatter wrists, and one reviewer felt the 42mm case was too large and flashy. The Zenith Defy Skyline Chronograph is seen by some as a great value, especially on the grey market, while others find its pricing steep.