lug2lug
BrowseCompareNewsCommunityMy Watches
BrowseCompareNewsCommunityMy Watches
Theme
Popular microbrands:Christopher Ward·Baltic·anOrdain·Atelier Wen·Boldr·Bremont·Dan Henry·DOXABrowse all →
Best, by the specs:Best dress watches·Diver under $2,000·Chronograph under $5,000·Sport under $5,000·GMT under $5,000·Field under $500·Pilot under $2,000·Casual under $1,000All rankings →
Glossary:Lug-to-Lug·Water Resistance·Chronograph·GMT·Automatic·LumeBrowse all →
Tools:Collection tracker·Wrist-fit calculator·What should I buy?·Value retention rankings·iPhone app
Lug2Letter
Watches worth knowing about, weekly.
Curated discoveries, founder spotlights, and the occasional deep-dive.
Get the app
Download on theApp StoreGET IT ONGoogle Play
TermsPrivacyCopyrightDisclosuresContactContribute

Independent reference site · not affiliated with any brand · contains affiliate links

© 2026 Lug2Lug LLC · Prices are estimates and not offers

Browse/Alternatives/Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Finding alternatives to

Alternatives to the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze

59 watches that match on case size, movement family, and price band. Sorted by how close the match is.

Case
39mm
Movement
Automatic
The short answer

The closest alternative to the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze is the Tudor Black Bay 58 925 — shared caliber (Tudor MT5400) and Same family (Black). If price is the constraint, the Rolex GMT-Master II at $11,800 covers most of the same brief. From the independents, the IXDAO Bronze 39mm Automatic Dive Watch is the standout microbrand take — pro diver and Looks nearly identical.

59 matches

Microbrand picks· 12

Independent makers covering the same brief — usually with something the mainstream brands don't.

IXDAO Bronze 39mm Automatic Dive Watch
IXDAOmicro
ixdao dive watch

Bronze 39mm Automatic Dive Watch

4 variants
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$269MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Colomer & Sons SOLD OUT – Navy Quartermaster
Colomer & Sonsmicro

SOLD OUT – Navy Quartermaster

 
40mm·Automatic·100m WR
$325MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Direnzo Watches DRZ 03 Eclipse black – date
Direnzo Watchesmicro

DRZ 03 Eclipse black – date

6 variants
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
—MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Colomer & Sons Scuba
Colomer & Sonsmicro

Scuba

 
40mm·Automatic·100m WR
$595MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Thorn Octopus 39mm BB58 Automatic Watch Rivet Bracelet
Thornmicro

Octopus 39mm BB58 Automatic Watch Rivet Bracelet

2 variants
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$233MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Ergon Watches Maelstrom
Ergon Watchesmicro

Maelstrom

3 variants
40mm·Automatic·300m WR
$380MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Wicked Watch Pearl Diver Phoenix
Wicked Watchmicro

Pearl Diver Phoenix

 
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
$738MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Revelot Hexmariner 39 Blue Aventurine Bicolor Steel
Revelotmicro

Hexmariner 39 Blue Aventurine Bicolor Steel

 
39mm·Automatic
$410MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Monterey Watch Co. Dark Bayou EM
Monterey Watch Co.micro

Dark Bayou EM

 
40mm·Automatic
$339MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
AETHELSOHN Horizon GMT Automatic Watch
AETHELSOHN

Horizon GMT Automatic Watch

2 variants
38mm·Automatic·200m WR
$245MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Raven Trekker
Ravenmicro

Trekker

6 variants
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$690MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Boderry SEATURTLE.OCEAN - Automatic Bronze Diving Watch
Boderrymicro

SEATURTLE.OCEAN - Automatic Bronze Diving Watch

 
40mm·Automatic·100m WR
$199MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze

Mainstream picks· 12

Established brands covering the same brief at a comparable price — same case size, similar movement family. Often the deciding click for a new buyer.

Tudor Black Bay 58 925
Tudor

Black Bay 58 925

 
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
—MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Tudor Black Bay 54
Tudor

Black Bay 54

2 variants
37mm·Automatic·200m WR
—MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Tudor Black Bay 58 18K
Tudor

Black Bay 58 18K

 
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
—MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Omega Seamaster 300 Co Axial Master Chronometer 41mm
Omega

Seamaster 300 Co Axial Master Chronometer 41mm

5 variants · Seamaster
41mm·Automatic·300m WR
$15,700MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Rolex Yacht-Master
Rolex

Yacht-Master

Ref. 16628
40mm·Automatic·100m WR
—MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Rolex Submariner Date
Rolex

Submariner Date

2 variants · Submariner
41mm·Automatic·300m WR
$19,450MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Rolex GMT-Master II
Rolex

GMT-Master II

Ref. 126711CHNR
40mm·Automatic·100m WR
$20,050MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Breitling Superocean Automatic
Breitling

Superocean Automatic

Ref. R17375211B1S1
42mm·Automatic·300m WR
$25,400MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Omega Seamaster Diver 300M Co Axial Master Chronometer 42mm
Omega

Seamaster Diver 300M Co Axial Master Chronometer 42mm

8 variants · Seamaster Diver 300M
42mm·Automatic·300m WR
$16,600MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Blancpain Fifty Fathoms Automatique
Blancpain

Fifty Fathoms Automatique

3 variants · Fifty Fathoms
38.2mm·Automatic·300m WR
$37,100MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Omega Seamaster Diver 300M 007 Edition
Omega

Seamaster Diver 300M 007 Edition

Ref. 210.90.42.20.01.003
42mm·Automatic·300m WR
$33,300MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Blancpain Fifty Fathoms Automatique
Blancpain

Fifty Fathoms Automatique

3 variants · Fifty Fathoms
38.2mm·Automatic·300m WR
$36,300MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze

Cheaper alternatives· 12

If the price is the only thing keeping you off this watch, these get you most of the way there for less.

Rolex GMT-Master II
Rolex

GMT-Master II

Ref. 126710BLNR
40mm·Automatic·100m WR
$11,800MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Tudor Black Bay Chrono
Tudor

Black Bay Chrono

5 variants
41mm·Automatic·200m WR
$7,000MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Glycine Unisex Combat Sub Bronze 39mm Automatic Watch GL0517
Glycine

Unisex Combat Sub Bronze 39mm Automatic Watch GL0517

8 variants
39mm·Automatic·300m WR
$1,550MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Tudor Black Bay 58 79030
Tudor

Black Bay 58 79030

2 variants
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$4,000MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Glycine Men's Combat Sub Sport 39mm Automatic Watch GL0403
Glycine
Combat

Men's Combat Sub Sport 39mm Automatic Watch GL0403

 
39mm·Automatic·300m WR
$1,650MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Longines HYDROCONQUEST MESH
Longines

HYDROCONQUEST MESH

2 variants · HydroConquest
41mm·Automatic·300m WR
$2,350MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Rolex Submariner Date
Rolex

Submariner Date

Ref. 126610LN
41mm·Automatic·300m WR
$11,350MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Yema Superman Bronze CMM.10
Yema

Superman Bronze CMM.10

4 variants · Superman
39mm·Automatic·300m WR
$1,699MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Breitling Avenger Automatic 42 America250
Breitling

Avenger Automatic 42 America250

 
42mm·Automatic·300m WR
$5,100MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Breitling Superocean Heritage B31 Automatic
Breitling

Superocean Heritage B31 Automatic

2 variants · Superocean Heritage
42/44mm·Automatic·200m WR
$8,050MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Longines LONGINES SPIRIT ZULU TIME
Longines
Spirit Zulu Time

LONGINES SPIRIT ZULU TIME

Ref. L3.802.5.53.6
39mm·Automatic·100m WR
$5,200MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Glycine Men's Combat Sub Bronze 42mm Automatic Watch GL0389
Glycine
Combat

Men's Combat Sub Bronze 42mm Automatic Watch GL0389

 
42mm·Automatic·200m WR
$1,530MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze

Pricier alternatives· 12

Where the same idea goes when budget isn't the constraint — luxury upgrades and step-ups.

Rolex GMT-Master II
Rolex

GMT-Master II

3 variants · Ref. 126718GRNR
40mm·Automatic·100m WR
$50,800MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Rolex Submariner Date
Rolex

Submariner Date

2 variants · Submariner
41mm·Automatic·300m WR
$50,900MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Rolex Rolex Deepsea
Rolex
Deepsea

Rolex Deepsea

Ref. 136668LB
44mm·Automatic·3900m WR
$68,100MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Patek Philippe Aquanaut 5261
Patek Philippemicro

Aquanaut 5261

Ref. 5261
39.9mm·Automatic
$72,394MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Blancpain Fifty Fathoms Automatique
Blancpain

Fifty Fathoms Automatique

Ref. 5015-3603C-63B
45mm·Automatic·300m WR
$52,600MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Patek Philippe Complications 4947
Patek Philippemicro

Complications 4947

Ref. 4947
38mm·Automatic
$57,890MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
IWC Schaffhausen Iw328901 Ingenieur Automatic
IWC Schaffhausen
Ingenieur

Iw328901 Ingenieur Automatic

Ref. IW328702
40mm·Automatic·100m WR
$55,600MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Patek Philippe Nautilus 5712
Patek Philippemicro

Nautilus 5712

Ref. 5712
40mm·Automatic
$97,650MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Breitling Top Time B21 Ford Mustang
Breitling

Top Time B21 Ford Mustang

2 variants · Top Time
42mm·Automatic·100m WR
$51,500MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Blancpain Villeret Quantième Annuel GMT
Blancpain

Villeret Quantième Annuel GMT

2 variants · Villeret
40mm·Automatic
$55,100MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Breitling Premier B19 Datora 42 140th Anniversary
Breitling

Premier B19 Datora 42 140th Anniversary

Ref. RB19401A1B1P1
42mm·Automatic·100m WR
$65,550MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Jaeger-LeCoultre Master Control Chronometre Date
Jaeger-LeCoultre

Master Control Chronometre Date

Ref. Q415216J
38mm·Automatic
$52,500MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze

Homages & lookalikes· 11

Watches that share this design language — confirmed homages, close tributes, and lookalikes, including the classics that inspired the look. Hidden when nothing in the catalog is related.

Baltany Retro Diving Wristwatch 200m Water Ghost S3024
Baltanyhomage

Retro Diving Wristwatch 200m Water Ghost S3024

 
42mm
—MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
San Martin Watchdives WD1016C 37mm Pioneer VH31 Men Watch
San Martinhomage

Watchdives WD1016C 37mm Pioneer VH31 Men Watch

3 variants
37mm·Quartz·100m WR
$109MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
San Martin BB36 Explore 36mm
San Martinhomage

BB36 Explore 36mm

2 variants
37mm·Automatic·100m WR
$346MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Cronos Thorn 40mm PT5000 Automatic Dive Watch T023 V3
Cronoshomage

Thorn 40mm PT5000 Automatic Dive Watch T023 V3

3 variants
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
$199MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
San Martin San Martin Retro Diver NH35 SN0008
San Martinhomage

San Martin Retro Diver NH35 SN0008

2 variants
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
$178MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Cronos Watchdives WD7922 37mm VH31 Watch
Cronoshomage

Watchdives WD7922 37mm VH31 Watch

5 variants
37mm·Quartz·200m WR
$99MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Cronos Snowflake BB39 Jubilee (L6026)
Cronoshomage
Bb39Cronos Bb39

Snowflake BB39 Jubilee (L6026)

4 variants · Cronos Bb39
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$188MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Pagani Design PD-1755
Pagani Designhomage
Automatic

PD-1755

3 variants
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
$162MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
STEELDIVE SD1952V
STEELDIVEhomage

SD1952V

 
41mm·Automatic·300m WR
$150MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
STEELDIVE SD1966S
STEELDIVEhomage

SD1966S

 
41.5mm·Automatic·200m WR
$198MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Pagani Design PD-1818
Pagani Designhomage
Automatic

PD-1818

2 variants
42mm·Automatic·100m WR
$171MSRP
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
← Back to the Tudor Black Bay 58 BronzeOpen the alternatives engine