lug2lug
BrowseCompareNewsCommunityMy Watches
BrowseCompareNewsCommunityMy Watches
Theme
Popular microbrands:Christopher Ward·Baltic·anOrdain·Atelier Wen·Boldr·Bremont·Dan Henry·DOXABrowse all →
Best, by the specs:Diver under $2,000·Dress under $5,000·Chronograph under $5,000·Best sport watches·GMT under $5,000·Field under $500·Pilot under $2,000·Casual under $1,000All rankings →
Glossary:Lug-to-Lug·Water Resistance·Chronograph·GMT·Automatic·LumeBrowse all →
Tools:Collection tracker·Watch size chart·Wrist-fit calculator·Selling calculator·What should I buy?·Market index·iPhone app
Lug2Letter
Watches worth knowing about, weekly.
Curated discoveries, founder spotlights, and the occasional deep-dive.
Get the app
Download on theApp StoreGET IT ONGoogle Play
TermsPrivacyDelete accountCopyrightDisclosuresContactContribute

Independent reference site · not affiliated with any brand · contains affiliate links

© 2026 Lug2Lug LLC · Prices are estimates and not offers

Watches/Alternatives/Tudor Black Bay 58 18K

Watch alternatives

Alternatives to the Tudor Black Bay 58 18K

Keep what you like. Explore what could be different. Compare 60 catalog matches by dimensions, movement and price.

Explore the matches ↓View original watch ↗
Case diameter
39 mm
Lug-to-lug
Not recorded
Movement
Automatic
Catalog MSRP
Not recorded
Tudor Black Bay 58 18KThe starting point
Your next watch starts with a shortlist.

Save favorites here, compare the details, and keep your collection with you in the app.

Explore the app ↗My watches ↗

Starting points

Choose the differences that matter to you.

Closest catalog matchTudor Black Bay 5437 mm case, 2 mm narrowerSee the match ↓

Calculated from catalog specifications and similarity signals. Prices are recorded MSRP in USD, not current retail offers. Missing measurements stay unknown.

Your priorities

Narrow these matches without leaving the page.

ColorwayPick a colorway to match a specific dial
60 matches

Microbrand picks· 12

Discover smaller makers with catalog similarities to this watch.

Héron Watches Marinor
Héron Watches

Marinor

  • Same 39 mm case diameter
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.2 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
AV86 1926 Automatic
AV86

1926 Automatic

  • Same 39 mm case diameter
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.7 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Alcadus Watches Dromo - Black - Alcadus Watches
Alcadus Watches

Dromo - Black - Alcadus Watches

  • Same 39 mm case diameter
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

Dimensions alone do not establish wrist fit.

View watch ↗
Carlingue Timepieces CARL-DIV-01 / CT-001-A
Carlingue Timepieces

CARL-DIV-01 / CT-001-A

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.8 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Méraud Bonaire
Méraud

Bonaire

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.5 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Squale Super-Squale
Squale

Super-Squale

  • 38 mm case, 1 mm narrower
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.7 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Circula Watches AquaSport II
Circula Watches

AquaSport II

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

Dimensions alone do not establish wrist fit.

View watch ↗
Jack Mason Pursuit Pro
Jack Mason

Pursuit Pro

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.2 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Alkin Watches Model Three Diver
Alkin Watches

Model Three Diver

  • 40.5 mm case, 1.5 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.2 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Buyalov НВЧ-20
Buyalov

НВЧ-20

  • 39.6 mm case, 0.6 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

Lug-to-lug is not recorded for this match.

View watch ↗
Nautage Diver II
Nautage

Diver II

  • 41 mm case, 2 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.7 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Spinnaker Spence 300
Spinnaker

Spence 300

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

1.2 mm thinner case

View watch ↗

Mainstream picks· 12

Established-brand matches. Compare the recorded dimensions, movement and price for each watch.

Tudor Black Bay 54
Tudor

Black Bay 54

  • 37 mm case, 2 mm narrower
  • Same Tudor MT5400 caliber
What changes

1.5 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Compare models ↗
Tudor Black Bay 58 925
Tudor

Black Bay 58 925

  • Same 39 mm case diameter
  • Same Tudor MT5400 caliber
What changes

Lug-to-lug is not recorded for this match.

View watch ↗
Compare models ↗
Omega Seamaster Diver 300M Co Axial Master Chronometer 42mm
Omega

Seamaster Diver 300M Co Axial Master Chronometer 42mm

  • 42 mm case, 3 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.9 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Omega Seamaster Diver 300M Co Axial Master Chronometer 42mm
Omega

Seamaster Diver 300M Co Axial Master Chronometer 42mm

  • 42 mm case, 3 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.9 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Tudor

Black Bay 58 Bronze

  • Same 39 mm case diameter
  • Same Tudor MT5400 caliber
What changes

0.8 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Compare models ↗
Breitling Superocean Automatic
Breitling

Superocean Automatic

  • 42 mm case, 3 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.1 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Breitling Premier B09 Chronograph 40
Breitling

Premier B09 Chronograph 40

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
What changes

Manual movement instead of automatic. 0.4 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Blancpain Fifty Fathoms Automatique
Blancpain

Fifty Fathoms Automatique

  • 38.2 mm case, 0.8 mm narrower
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.7 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Blancpain Fifty Fathoms Automatique
Blancpain

Fifty Fathoms Automatique

  • 38.2 mm case, 0.8 mm narrower
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.7 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Omega Seamaster Diver 300M 007 Edition
Omega

Seamaster Diver 300M 007 Edition

  • 42 mm case, 3 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

1.1 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Breitling Superocean Heritage B31 Automatic 40 Kelly Slater
Breitling

Superocean Heritage B31 Automatic 40 Kelly Slater

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

1 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Rolex Yacht-Master
Rolex

Yacht-Master

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

Lug-to-lug is not recorded for this match.

View watch ↗

Cheaper alternatives· 12

Matches in a lower price band. A recorded MSRP difference is shown only when both prices are known.

Breitling Superocean Heritage 57 Highlands
Breitling

Superocean Heritage 57 Highlands

  • 38 mm case, 1 mm narrower
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

3.3 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Bremont Supermarine 300M
Bremont

Supermarine 300M

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.7 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Breitling Superocean Automatic
Breitling

Superocean Automatic

  • 42 mm case, 3 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.1 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Breitling Superocean Automatic
Breitling

Superocean Automatic

  • 42 mm case, 3 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.1 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Omega Seamaster Diver 300M Co Axial Master Chronometer 42mm
Omega

Seamaster Diver 300M Co Axial Master Chronometer 42mm

  • 42 mm case, 3 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.9 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Bremont S302
Bremont

S302

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.3 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Glycine Men's Combat Sub Sport 39mm Automatic Watch GL0404
Glycine

Men's Combat Sub Sport 39mm Automatic Watch GL0404

  • Same 39 mm case diameter
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

Lug-to-lug is not recorded for this match.

View watch ↗
Norqain Adventure 40mm
Norqain

Adventure 40mm

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.1 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Bremont Supermarine 500M
Bremont

Supermarine 500M

  • 43 mm case, 4 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.3 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Yema Superman Gilt CMM.10
Yema

Superman Gilt CMM.10

  • Same 39 mm case diameter
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

1.4 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Seiko Prospex Sea 1968 Heritage Diver's GMT
Seiko

Prospex Sea 1968 Heritage Diver's GMT

  • 42 mm case, 3 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.2 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Seiko Prospex Sea 1965 Heritage Diver's Watch PADI Special Edition
Seiko

Prospex Sea 1965 Heritage Diver's Watch PADI Special Edition

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.3 mm thicker case

View watch ↗

Pricier alternatives· 12

Matches in a higher price band. Check the specifications to decide whether the differences matter to you.

Omega Seamaster 300 Co Axial Master Chronometer 41mm
Omega

Seamaster 300 Co Axial Master Chronometer 41mm

  • 41 mm case, 2 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

1.2 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Rolex GMT-Master II
Rolex

GMT-Master II

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

Lug-to-lug is not recorded for this match.

View watch ↗
Rolex Cosmograph Daytona
Rolex

Cosmograph Daytona

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

Lug-to-lug is not recorded for this match.

View watch ↗
Omega Speedmaster Moonwatch Professional Co Axial Master Chronometer Chronograph 42mm
Omega

Speedmaster Moonwatch Professional Co Axial Master Chronometer Chronograph 42mm

  • 42 mm case, 3 mm wider
What changes

Manual movement instead of automatic. 0.5 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Rolex Submariner Date
Rolex

Submariner Date

  • 41 mm case, 2 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

Lug-to-lug is not recorded for this match.

View watch ↗
Omega Speedmaster 38 Co Axial Chronometer Chronograph 38mm
Omega

Speedmaster 38 Co Axial Chronometer Chronograph 38mm

  • 38 mm case, 1 mm narrower
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

2 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Panerai Submersible Mike Horn
Panerai

Submersible Mike Horn

  • 44 mm case, 5 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

Lug-to-lug is not recorded for this match.

View watch ↗
Patek Philippe Complications 5930
Patek Philippe

Complications 5930

  • 39.5 mm case, 0.5 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.2 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Panerai Submersible
Panerai

Submersible

  • 42 mm case, 3 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.5 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Panerai Submersible Luna Rossa
Panerai

Submersible Luna Rossa

  • 42 mm case, 3 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.5 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Breitling Top Time B21 Ford Mustang
Breitling

Top Time B21 Ford Mustang

  • 42 mm case, 3 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

2.7 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Patek Philippe Complications 5172
Patek Philippe

Complications 5172

  • 41 mm case, 2 mm wider
What changes

Manual movement instead of automatic. 1.3 mm thinner case

View watch ↗

Homages & lookalikes· 12

Watches that share this design language: confirmed homages, close tributes, and lookalikes, including the classics that inspired the look. Hidden when nothing in the catalog is related.

Addiesdive 39mm Quartz Watch with Bi-directional Rotating Bezel AD2072
Addiesdive

39mm Quartz Watch with Bi-directional Rotating Bezel AD2072

  • Same 39 mm case diameter
What changes

Quartz movement instead of automatic. 0.7 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Addiesdive 40mm Dive Watch Automatic Scuba Watch AD2101
Addiesdive

40mm Dive Watch Automatic Scuba Watch AD2101

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.3 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Addiesdive U.S. -ADDIESDIVE Retro Baton Hand Sub NH35 Dive Watch AD2086
Addiesdive

U.S. -ADDIESDIVE Retro Baton Hand Sub NH35 Dive Watch AD2086

  • 42.6 mm case, 3.6 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.5 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Baltany Retro Diving Wristwatch 200m Water Ghost S3024
Baltany

Retro Diving Wristwatch 200m Water Ghost S3024

  • 42 mm case, 3 mm wider
What changes

Lug-to-lug is not recorded for this match.

View watch ↗
Cronos BB54 Vintage Diver 39mm (L6052)
Cronos

BB54 Vintage Diver 39mm (L6052)

  • Same 39 mm case diameter
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

1.4 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Cronos Snowflake BB39 Jubilee (L6025)
Cronos

Snowflake BB39 Jubilee (L6025)

  • Same 39 mm case diameter
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.6 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Cronos Snowflake BB39 Jubilee (L6026)
Cronos

Snowflake BB39 Jubilee (L6026)

  • Same 39 mm case diameter
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

0.6 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
Pagani Design PD-1755
Pagani Design

PD-1755

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

1.3 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
Pagani Design PD-1818
Pagani Design

PD-1818

  • 42 mm case, 3 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

1.8 mm thicker case

View watch ↗
San Martin BB36 Explore 36mm
San Martin

BB36 Explore 36mm

  • 37 mm case, 2 mm narrower
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

1.4 mm thinner case

View watch ↗
San Martin BB58 NH35 Automatic Watch SN008C
San Martin

BB58 NH35 Automatic Watch SN008C

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

Lug-to-lug is not recorded for this match.

View watch ↗
San Martin 2025 Upgraded 40mm Diver Watch SN0118G-B
San Martin

2025 Upgraded 40mm Diver Watch SN0118G-B

  • 40 mm case, 1 mm wider
  • Both use automatic movements
What changes

Lug-to-lug is not recorded for this match.

View watch ↗
Keep your wishlist and collection together on iPhone and AndroidExplore the app
Get the appGet the app

Keep exploring

Follow a detail, a style, or a new direction.

Check your wrist fit ↗

Explore how case diameter and lug-to-lug relate to your wrist.

Find your watch style ↗

Use the quiz to explore watches around your preferences.

Browse watches ↗

Explore more brands, sizes and styles across the catalog.