Which is cheaper, the Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic or the Hamilton American Classic Day Date Auto?

At MSRP the Hamilton American Classic Day Date Auto is the cheaper of the two at $1,245, against $2,500 for the Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic — a $1,255 gap before any retailer discounting.

Which is bigger, the Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic or the Hamilton American Classic Day Date Auto?

The Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic wears larger at 46mm versus 42mm for the Hamilton American Classic Day Date Auto — a 4mm difference across the dial.

Which has better water resistance, the Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic or the Hamilton American Classic Day Date Auto?

The Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic is rated to 300m versus 50m for the Hamilton American Classic Day Date Auto.

Which has a longer power reserve, the Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic or the Hamilton American Classic Day Date Auto?

The Hamilton American Classic Day Date Auto carries a 80-hour power reserve against 40 hours on the Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic.

What movement does the Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic run compared to the Hamilton American Classic Day Date Auto?

Both watches run automatic movements — the Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic uses the Sellita SW220-1 and the Hamilton American Classic Day Date Auto uses the H-30.

Side by side

Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm AutomaticvsHamilton American Classic Day Date Auto

The numbers, the dial colors, the calibers — laid out so you can stop flipping between tabs.

Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic

46mm-arctic-original-sar-w-date-on-3-piece-rubber-strap-kit-osar-d

MSRP $2,500

Hamilton American Classic Day Date Auto

h35415982

MSRP $1,245

At a glance

11 of 29 specs differ

Diameter

Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic46mm

American Classic Day Date Auto42mm

Power Reserve

Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic40h

American Classic Day Date Auto80h

Water Resistance

Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic300m

American Classic Day Date Auto50m

MSRP

Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic$2,500

American Classic Day Date Auto$1,245

Full specifications

Case

7 specs

Crystal & Dial

1 specs

Dial Color

White

Grey

Movement

2 specs

Caliber

Sellita SW220-1

H-30

Power Reserve

40h

80h

Pricing

1 specs

MSRP

$2,500

$1,245

Follow this matchup

Get a note when Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic vs Hamilton American Classic Day Date Auto gets more votes, a community discussion, or a price drop. No account needed.

What people say

Owners + reviewers, side by side

Synthesized for each watch independently from owner discussions, enthusiast forums, written reviews, and video reviewers.

Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic

Owners widely praise the Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic for its overbuilt toughness and industrial, instrument-like aesthetic, with some preferring the Arctic dial for legibility. One owner notes the automatic movement may be unnecessary for rough use compared to a quartz option. Reviewers mention the MaraGlo luminous paint and a Sellita SW200-1 automatic movement. Some owners question its rising price and luxury positioning, with one reporting poor lume and movement performance. Overall, owners value the Marathon Arctic OSAR 46mm Automatic for its robust build and utilitarian design.

Reddit·3

A Blog to Watch

Hamilton American Classic Day Date Auto

Owners widely praise the Hamilton American Classic Day Date Auto for its legible dial, well-integrated day-date complication, and vintage military aesthetic. The 40mm to 42mm case is noted to wear smaller than its dimensions suggest, and the complication is considered well-executed for its price point. However, the lume is criticized for poor intensity and longevity, and the mirror-polished bezel is flagged as a scratch magnet. The stock leather strap is also described as stiff. Overall, owners rate the Hamilton American Classic Day Date Auto highly for its attractive vintage styling and functional day-date complication at an accessible price.

WatchUSeek·2

Keep exploring