lug2lug
BrowseBrandsCompareDiscussionCommunity WatchesMy Watches
BrowseBrandsCompareDiscussionCommunity WatchesMy Watches
Theme
Popular microbrands:Christopher Ward·Baltic·anOrdain·Atelier Wen·Boldr·Bremont·Dan Henry·DOXABrowse all →
Best, by the specs:Best dress watches·Diver under $5,000·Chronograph under $5,000·Sport under $5,000·GMT under $5,000·Field under $2,000·Best tool watches·Pilot under $2,000All rankings →
Glossary:Lug-to-Lug·Water Resistance·Chronograph·GMT·Automatic·LumeBrowse all →
Tools:Collection tracker·Wrist-fit calculator·What should I buy?·Value retention rankings·iPhone app
Lug2Letter
Watches worth knowing about, weekly.
Curated discoveries, founder spotlights, and the occasional deep-dive.
Now on iPhone
Download on theApp Store
TermsPrivacyCopyrightDisclosuresContactContribute

Independent reference site · not affiliated with any brand · contains affiliate links

© 2026 Lug2Lug LLC · Prices are estimates and not offers

Browse/Alternatives/Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Finding alternatives to

Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze

Ref. m79012m-0001

57 watches that match on case size, movement family, and price band. Sorted by how close the match is.

Case
39mm
Movement
Automatic
Category
Diver
MSRP
$5,850
The short answer

The closest alternative to the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze is the Tudor Black Bay 58 925 ($5,600) — shared caliber (Tudor MT5400) and Same family (Black Bay). If price is the constraint, the Yema Superman Bronze CMM.10 at $1,699 (vs $5,850 for the Black Bay 58 Bronze) covers most of the same brief. From the independents, the Carlingue Timepieces CARL-DIV-01 / CT-001-A is the standout microbrand take — skin-diver style and Looks nearly identical. Stepping up, the Tudor Black Bay 58 18K ($22,550) is where the same idea goes with a bigger budget.

57 matches
Microbrand picks· 12

Independent makers covering the same brief — usually with something the mainstream brands don't.

Carlingue Timepieces CARL-DIV-01 / CT-001-A
Carlingue Timepiecesmicro

CARL-DIV-01 / CT-001-A

15 variantsSeries
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
$974MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Lorier Neptune SIV
Loriermicro

Neptune SIV

39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$599MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Islander Islander Hudson "Harpoon Diver" 40mm Watch with Degrading Black Dial #ISL-302
Islandermicro
Under $50

Islander Hudson "Harpoon Diver" 40mm Watch with Degrading Black Dial #ISL-302

2 variantsUnder $50
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
$649MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Specht & Sohne Specht & Söhne SP2653 Automatic
Specht & Sohnemicro
SP2653

Specht & Söhne SP2653 Automatic

4 variantsRef. SP2653A1
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$361MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Baltic Aquascaphe Bronze
Balticmicro

Aquascaphe Bronze

3 variantsAquascaphe Bronze
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$697MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Elliot Brown BEACHMASTER AUTOMATIC: 0H0-A02-B12
Elliot Brownmicro

BEACHMASTER AUTOMATIC: 0H0-A02-B12

40mm·Automatic·300m WR
$2,820MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Vero Watch Company Open Water 41
Vero Watch Companymicro

Open Water 41

7 variantsSeries
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
$890MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Aigi Watches ARCTIC TIDE
Aigi Watchesmicro

ARCTIC TIDE

3 variantsSeries
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
$875MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Venezianico Nereide Bronzo 39
Venezianicomicro

Nereide Bronzo 39

2 variantsNereide Bronzo 39
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$925MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Vaer D5 Tropic Auto
Vaermicro
Tropic

D5 Tropic Auto

39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$699MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Henry Archer Nordsø
Henry Archermicro

Nordsø

33 variantsNordsø
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
$521MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
IXDAO Bronze 39mm Automatic Dive Watch
IXDAOmicro
ixdao dive watch

Bronze 39mm Automatic Dive Watch

4 variantsSeries
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$269MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Mainstream picks· 12

Established brands covering the same brief at a comparable price — same case size, similar movement family. Often the deciding click for a new buyer.

Tudor Black Bay 58 925
Tudor

Black Bay 58 925

Ref. m79010sg-0001
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$5,600MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Tudor Black Bay 58
Tudor

Black Bay 58

Ref. m7939a1a0nu-0001
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$5,350MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Tudor Black Bay 54
Tudor

Black Bay 54

Ref. m79000b-0001
37mm·Automatic·200m WR
$4,725MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Omega Seamaster 300 Co Axial Master Chronometer 41mm
Omega

Seamaster 300 Co Axial Master Chronometer 41mm

3 variantsSeamaster
41mm·Automatic·300m WR
$8,000MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Bremont Supermarine 300M
Bremont

Supermarine 300M

8 variantsSupermarine
40mm·Automatic·300m WR
$3,550MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Rolex Submariner
Rolex

Submariner

Ref. 124060
41mm·Automatic·300m WR
$10,050MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Rolex Submariner Date
Rolex

Submariner Date

Ref. 126610LN
41mm·Automatic·300m WR
$11,350MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Breitling Superocean Heritage 57 Highlands
Breitling

Superocean Heritage 57 Highlands

4 variantsSuperocean Heritage
38mm·Automatic·100m WR
$6,900MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Omega Seamaster Diver 300M Co Axial Master Chronometer 42mm
Omega

Seamaster Diver 300M Co Axial Master Chronometer 42mm

25 variantsSeamaster Diver 300M
42mm·Automatic·300m WR
$6,300MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Breitling Superocean Automatic
Breitling

Superocean Automatic

36/42/44/46mm
19 variantsSuperocean
36/42/44/46mm·Automatic·300m WR
$5,700MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Bremont S302
Bremont
Supermarine

S302

6 variantsSupermarine
40mm·Automatic·300m WR
$3,900MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Bremont S502
Bremont
Supermarine

S502

3 variantsSupermarine
43mm·Automatic·500m WR
$5,100MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Cheaper alternatives· 12

If the price is the only thing keeping you off this watch, these get you most of the way there for less.

Yema Superman Bronze CMM.10
Yema

Superman Bronze CMM.10

4 variantsSuperman
39mm·Automatic·300m WR
$1,699MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Seiko Prospex Sea Seiko Prospex 1965 Heritage Diver’s Watch Save the Ocean Limited Edition
Seiko

Prospex Sea Seiko Prospex 1965 Heritage Diver’s Watch Save the Ocean Limited Edition

40mm·Automatic·300m WR
$1,400MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Seiko Prospex Sea 1965 Heritage Diver's Watch
Seiko

Prospex Sea 1965 Heritage Diver's Watch

2 variantsProspex Sea
40mm·Automatic·300m WR
$1,300MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Glycine Unisex Combat Sub Bronze 39mm Automatic Watch GL0517
Glycine

Unisex Combat Sub Bronze 39mm Automatic Watch GL0517

7 variantsSeries
39mm·Automatic·300m WR
$1,550MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Yema Diver
Yema

Diver

2 variantsDiver
39.5mm·Automatic·200m WR
$990MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Longines HYDROCONQUEST MESH
Longines

HYDROCONQUEST MESH

2 variantsHydroConquest
41mm·Automatic·300m WR
$2,350MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Orient AC0Q Diver II LE
Orient

AC0Q Diver II LE

6 variantsSeries
39.9mm·Automatic·200m WR
$395MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Yema Navygraf Marine Nationale CMM.10
Yema

Navygraf Marine Nationale CMM.10

2 variantsNavygraf
39mm·Automatic·100m WR
$1,614MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Orient AC0Q-40 Diver Watch
Orient
DiverAC0Q

AC0Q-40 Diver Watch

6 variantsAC0Q
39.9mm·Automatic·200m WR
$370MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Longines HYDROCONQUEST
Longines

HYDROCONQUEST

39/41mm
22 variantsHydroConquest
39/41mm·Automatic·300m WR
$2,000MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Oris Oris X RedBar Limited Edition II
Oris
Divers

Oris X RedBar Limited Edition II

4 variantsDivers
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$2,950MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Seiko Prospex Sea
Seiko

Prospex Sea

2 variantsProspex Sea
42mm·Automatic·300m WR
—MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Pricier alternatives· 12

Where the same idea goes when budget isn't the constraint — luxury upgrades and step-ups.

Tudor Black Bay 58 18K
Tudor

Black Bay 58 18K

Ref. m79018v-0001
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$22,550MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Tudor Black Bay
Tudor

Black Bay

Ref. m79230g-0001
41mm·Automatic·200m WR
—MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Omega Seamaster 300 Co Axial Master Chronometer 41mm
Omega

Seamaster 300 Co Axial Master Chronometer 41mm

5 variantsSeamaster
41mm·Automatic·300m WR
$15,700MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Blancpain Fifty Fathoms Automatique
Blancpain

Fifty Fathoms Automatique

2 variantsFifty Fathoms
38.2mm·Automatic·300m WR
$37,100MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Blancpain Fifty Fathoms Automatique
Blancpain

Fifty Fathoms Automatique

2 variantsFifty Fathoms
38.2mm·Automatic·300m WR
$37,100MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Blancpain Fifty Fathoms Automatique
Blancpain

Fifty Fathoms Automatique

Ref. 5007-3644A-NABA
38.2mm·Automatic·300m WR
$37,100MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Breitling Superocean Heritage B31 Automatic 40 Kelly Slater
Breitling

Superocean Heritage B31 Automatic 40 Kelly Slater

Ref. AB31101A/CC61/225A
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
—MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Omega Seamaster Diver 300M Co Axial Master Chronometer 42mm
Omega

Seamaster Diver 300M Co Axial Master Chronometer 42mm

8 variantsSeamaster Diver 300M
42mm·Automatic·300m WR
$16,600MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Rolex Sea-Dweller
Rolex

Sea-Dweller

Ref. 126600
43mm·Automatic·1220m WR
$14,550MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Rolex Yacht-Master
Rolex

Yacht-Master

37/40mm
4 variantsYacht-Master
37/40mm·Automatic·100m WR
$12,500MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Rolex Submariner Date
Rolex

Submariner Date

2 variantsSubmariner
41mm·Automatic·300m WR
$50,900MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Breitling Superocean Automatic
Breitling

Superocean Automatic

Ref. R17375211B1S1
42mm·Automatic·300m WR
$25,400MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Homages & lookalikes· 9

Watches that share this design language — confirmed homages, close tributes, and lookalikes, including the classics that inspired the look. Hidden when nothing in the catalog is related.

San Martin San Martin Retro Diver NH35 SN0008
San Martinhomage

San Martin Retro Diver NH35 SN0008

2 variantsSeries
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
$178MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Pagani Design PD-1755
Pagani Designhomage
Automatic

PD-1755

3 variantsPD-1755
40mm·Automatic·200m WR
$162MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
San Martin San Martin Watchdives Seafarar WD5513Q 40mm VH31 Sub Diver
San Martinhomage

San Martin Watchdives Seafarar WD5513Q 40mm VH31 Sub Diver

5 variantsSeries
40mm·Quartz·200m WR
$145MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Cronos Snowflake BB39 Jubilee (L6026)
Cronoshomage
Bb39Cronos Bb39

Snowflake BB39 Jubilee (L6026)

4 variantsCronos Bb39
39mm
$188MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Baltany Retro Diving Wristwatch 200m Water Ghost S3024
Baltanyhomage

Retro Diving Wristwatch 200m Water Ghost S3024

42mm
—MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Cronos Snowflake BB39 Jubilee (L6025)
Cronoshomage
Bb39Cronos Bb39

Snowflake BB39 Jubilee (L6025)

4 variantsCronos Bb39
39mm
$198MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Cronos BB54 Vintage Diver 39mm (L6052)
Cronoshomage
Cronos 39mm

BB54 Vintage Diver 39mm (L6052)

4 variantsCronos 39mm
39mm·Automatic·200m WR
$255MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
San Martin Watchdives WD7922 37mm VH31 Watch
San Martinhomage

Watchdives WD7922 37mm VH31 Watch

4 variantsSeries
37mm·Quartz·200m WR
$99MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
Pagani Design PD-1818
Pagani Designhomage
Automatic

PD-1818

2 variantsPD-1818
42mm·Automatic·100m WR
$171MSRP
—Used
vsCompare with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Bronze
← Back to the Tudor Black Bay 58 BronzeBest Diver Watches Under $5,000 →Open the alternatives engine