Lilienthal Berlin Lilienthal 1 – Gold BluevsRedwood Watches Field v3 -

The Lilienthal Berlin Lilienthal 1 – Gold Blue draws mixed owner response. Strengths include satisfyingly finished hands, a clean dial, and scratch-resistant case and glass; the mesh bracelet is noted as comfortable, and owners appreciate the quartz movement and sapphire crystal as solid entry-level specs. However, the community reports significant inconsistency: sharp case edges and strap screws cause discomfort for some, one owner's SuperLuminova placement (hands only) disappointed them, and a crown detached unexpectedly on another unit. Quality control concerns recur across sources—some praise build quality and weight, while others flag machine-stamped finishing and report non-functional watches upon arrival. Customer service and shipping delays are widely flagged as problematic, though a few owners had positive experiences. Price skepticism appears, with one owner questioning whether the nearly $400 cost justifies the Ronda quartz movement and coated case.

Redwood Watches Field v3 - is praised by owners for its value under $200 USD and simple field watch design. One owner finds the 40mm case wears smaller than a 39.5mm Seiko 5. However, the lume is minimal and fades quickly. Overall, owners rate the Redwood Watches Field v3 - highly for its good value and comfortable wearability.