Sheffield 1A 40mm
Finding alternatives to

Sheffield 1A 40mm

45 watches that match on case size, movement family, and price band. Sorted by how close the match is.

Case
40mm
Movement
Automatic
MSRP
$228
The short answer

The closest alternative to the Sheffield 1A 40mm is the Arethusa Watch Co World Diver — shared caliber (Seiko NH35) and Visually similar. From the independents, the Sheffield 1A 38 dive 38mm, 3-hand date (rotating dive bezel, perforated rubber strap) is the standout microbrand take — shared caliber (Seiko NH35) and Same family (1A). Stepping up, the Audaz ADZ-3030 ($550) is where the same idea goes with a bigger budget.

45 matches
Microbrand picks· 12

Independent makers covering the same brief — usually with something the mainstream brands don't.

Sheffield
1A 38 dive 38mm, 3-hand date (rotating dive bezel, perforated rubber strap)
38mm · Automatic$223
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Same family (1A)
Shiro Kara
Daibāzu: Starby SUB
40mm · Automatic$458
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Looks nearly identical
Shiro Kara
Daibāzu: Kuro SUB
40mm · Automatic$518
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Looks nearly identical
Noctua Watch Corp.
PD-1
42mm · Automatic$429
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Looks nearly identical
Farr + Swit
Best Lume Dial Watch
40mm · Automatic$499
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Noctua Watch Corp.
P-1
42mm · Automatic$375
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Looks nearly identical
Oceanica Watch Co.
Thresher
40mm · Automatic$300
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Sheffield
1A SCR II Blue
40mm · Automatic$278
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Same family (1A)
Shiro Kara
Daibāzu: Cookie Monster SUB
40mm · Automatic$438
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Noctua Watch Corp.
Sentinel
42mm · Automatic$429
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Looks nearly identical
Olech & Wajs Watches
MV-82
39.5mm · Automatic$2,010
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Boldr
The T Rex By Boldr X Nitecore
40mm · Automatic$499
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Mainstream picks· 12

Established brands covering the same brief at a comparable price — same case size, similar movement family. Often the deciding click for a new buyer.

Arethusa Watch Co
World Diver
40mm · Automatic
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Audaz
Audaz Sea Ranger ADZ-2050
42mm · Automatic$375
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Alexander James Watches
A4 Legacy Dress 37 pilot/field 3-hand date, printed Arabic numerals (PVD cushion case)
37.4mm · Automatic$200
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Aigi Watches
NORTHERN LIGHTS AUTOMATIC
43mm · Automatic$443
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Alkin Watches
Model One
42mm · Automatic$342
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Automatic
Audaz
ADZ-2070
42mm · Automatic$450
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Automatic
Aigi Watches
BARENTS SEA AUTOMATIC round dive watch 43mm, applied markers + date + dive bezel
43mm · Automatic$180
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Automatic
Ajwain Watches
Sholavaram III
40mm · Automatic$395
Visually similar · Automatic
Alexander James Watches
A4 Legacy Dress 37
37.4mm · Automatic$250
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Automatic
Audaz
Reef Diver
45mm · Automatic$420
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Tudor
Black Bay
41mm · Automatic
Visually similar · Automatic
Aigi Watches
BARENTS SEA AUTOMATIC
43mm · Automatic$180
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Automatic
Pricier alternatives· 12

Where the same idea goes when budget isn't the constraint — luxury upgrades and step-ups.

Audaz
ADZ-3030
42mm · Automatic$550
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Audaz
ADZ-3040
42mm · Automatic$550
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Audaz
ADZ-3050
42mm · Automatic$550
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Aigi Watches
ARCTIC DIVER
41mm · Automatic$480
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Aigi Watches
Arctic Diver Black Dive Watch
41mm · Automatic$480
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Marathon
Jeep Rubicon GSAR
41mm · Automatic$2,100
Visually similar · Automatic
Alkin Watches
Model Two
41mm · Automatic$582
Visually similar · Automatic
Marathon
Jeep Rubicon TSAR
41mm · Automatic$1,650
Visually similar · Automatic
Aigi Watches
SATELLITE GROUND STATION
40.5mm · Automatic$516
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Automatic
Marathon
Arctic OSAR 41mm Automatic
41mm · Automatic$1,800
Visually similar · Automatic
Alexander James Watches
A4 Legacy X 37
37.4mm · Automatic$475
Visually similar · Automatic
Seiko
Prospex Sea
41mm · Automatic$900
Visually similar · Automatic
Looks like this· 9

Visually-adjacent picks pulled by the image-similarity engine. Quality varies — sometimes a true twin, sometimes just a rhyme.

Pagani Design
PD-1692 II AK
40mm · Automatic$125
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Pagani Design
PD-1653
40mm · Automatic$125
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Pagani Design
PD-YN009
40.7mm · Automatic$154
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Sugess
Ocean Star S450 YM
40mm · Automatic$449
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Sugess
Seestern 62MAS V3
39mm · Automatic$199
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Visually similar
Seestern
Sub 300 V4
42mm · Automatic$10
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Automatic
Sugess
Ocean Star S421
40mm · Automatic$449
Automatic · Same size
Seestern
S424 Full Lume Pilot
38mm · Automatic$299
Shared caliber (Seiko NH35) · Automatic
Seestern
S443 Column Wheel Chronograph
40mm · Manual$10
Visually similar · Same size