Finding alternatives to

58 watches that match on case size, movement family, and price band. Sorted by how close the match is.

Case
39mm
Movement
Automatic
MSRP
$3,490
The short answer

The closest alternative to the is the Marathon GSAR (Government Search & Rescue) Diver's Automatic ($2,100) — shared caliber (Sellita SW200-1) and Visually similar. If price is the constraint, the Aigi Watches RAAF at $1,032 (vs $3,490 for the ) covers most of the same brief. From the independents, the Circula Watches Ae St Bb is the standout microbrand take — shared caliber (Sellita SW200-1) and Looks nearly identical. Stepping up, the Tudor Black Bay 58 18K ($22,550) is where the same idea goes with a bigger budget.

58 matches
Microbrand picks· 12

Independent makers covering the same brief — usually with something the mainstream brands don't.

Circula Watches
Ae St Bb
40mm · Automatic$990
Shared caliber (Sellita SW200-1) · Looks nearly identical
Circula Watches
SuperSport
40mm · Automatic
Shared caliber (Sellita SW200-1) · Looks nearly identical
Z.R.C Grands Fonds Heritage
39mm · Automatic$3,290
Shared caliber (Sellita SW200-1) · Visually similar
Spinnaker
Tesei Bronze Swiss
43mm · Automatic$850
Shared caliber (Sellita SW200-1) · Looks nearly identical
Chronotechna
SeaQuest
42mm · Automatic$1,650
Shared caliber (Sellita SW200-1) · Looks nearly identical
Fortis
Flieger F-39
39mm · Automatic$2,530
Shared caliber (Sellita SW200-1) · Visually similar
Venezianico
Nereide Bronzo
42mm · Automatic$1,250
Shared caliber (Sellita SW200-1) · Looks nearly identical
Carlingue Timepieces
CARL-DIV-01 /
40mm · Automatic$974
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Circula Watches
AquaSport GMT
40mm · Automatic$1,490
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Eza
1972 Diver
39.6mm · Automatic$1,411
Shared caliber (Sellita SW200-1) · Visually similar
Decima
Scylla
44mm · Automatic$899
Shared caliber (Sellita SW200-1) · Looks nearly identical
Fortis
Flieger F-41
41mm · Automatic$2,530
Shared caliber (Sellita SW200-1) · Visually similar
Mainstream picks· 12

Established brands covering the same brief at a comparable price — same case size, similar movement family. Often the deciding click for a new buyer.

Marathon
GSAR (Government Search & Rescue) Diver's Automatic
41mm · Automatic$2,100
Shared caliber (Sellita SW200-1) · Visually similar
Seiko
Prospex Marinemaster Marinemaster 1965 Heritage Diver's Watch
39.5mm · Automatic$2,800
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Marathon
Jeep Rubicon GSAR
41mm · Automatic$2,100
Shared caliber (Sellita SW200-1) · Automatic
Seiko
Prospex Marinemaster Marinemaster 1965 Diver’s Modern Re-interpretation
39.5mm · Automatic$2,800
Visually similar · Automatic
Tudor
Black Bay Bronze
43mm · Automatic$5,425
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Glycine
Combat Sub Sport GMT Bronze
42mm · Automatic$2,995
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Marathon
OSAR-D (Original SAR with Date) Automatic 41mm
41mm · Automatic$1,800
Visually similar · Automatic
Airain Watches
Sous-Marine
37.5mm · Automatic$2,050
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Tudor
Black Bay 58 Bronze
39mm · Automatic$5,850
Visually similar · Automatic
Longines
LEGEND DIVER BRONZE
42mm · Automatic$3,550
Visually similar · Automatic
Longines
LONGINES SPIRIT ZULU TIME
39mm · Automatic$5,200
Visually similar · Automatic
Tudor
Black Bay 58
39mm · Automatic$5,350
Visually similar · Automatic
Cheaper alternatives· 12

If the price is the only thing keeping you off this watch, these get you most of the way there for less.

Aigi Watches
RAAF
40mm · Automatic$1,032
Shared caliber (Sellita SW200-1) · Visually similar
Glycine
Combat Sub Sport Bronze
39mm · Automatic$1,650
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Audaz
ADZ-2065
42mm · Automatic$600
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Aigi Watches
GRUVEBUS
40mm · Automatic$1,095
Visually similar · Automatic
Seiko
Prospex Sea 1965 Heritage Diver's Watch PADI Special Edition
40mm · Automatic$1,550
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Aigi Watches
1RSU
40mm · Automatic$910
Visually similar · Automatic
Citizen
Promaster Fujitsubo
41mm · Automatic$1,195
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Audaz
ADZ-3070
42mm · Automatic$700
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Seiko
Prospex Sea 1965 Heritage Diver's Save the Ocean Special Edition
40.5mm · Automatic$1,250
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Seiko
Prospex Sea 1965 Heritage Diver's Watch
40mm · Automatic$1,300
Visually similar · Automatic
Alexander James Watches
A4 Prelude 37 GMT Light Blue
37.4mm · Automatic$325
Visually similar · Automatic
Beaucroft Watches
Contour GMT
39.5mm · Automatic$1,067
Visually similar · Automatic
Pricier alternatives· 12

Where the same idea goes when budget isn't the constraint — luxury upgrades and step-ups.

Tudor
Black Bay 58 18K
39mm · Automatic$22,550
Visually similar · Automatic
Grand Seiko
SLGB023
40.8mm · Spring Drive$12,400
Visually similar · Similar size
Tudor
Black Bay Chrono S&G
41mm · Automatic$8,525
Visually similar · Automatic
Vacheron Constantin
Overseas Dual Time Cardinal Points East 41mm Titanium Watch
41mm · Automatic$41,000
Visually similar · Automatic
Grand Seiko
SLGA019
40mm · Spring Drive$11,000
Visually similar · Same size
Vacheron Constantin
Fiftysix Self Winding 40mm Pink Gold Watch
40mm · Automatic$29,200
Visually similar · Automatic
Bell & Ross
BR 03-92 DIVER BLUE BRONZE SAPPHIRE BEZEL
42mm · Automatic$8,532
Visually similar · Automatic
Bell & Ross
BRS-92 ROSE GOLD
39mm · Automatic$13,932
Visually similar · Automatic
Grand Seiko
SBGA384
40mm · Spring Drive$29,500
Same size · Sapphire
Hublot
Classic Fusion
38mm · Automatic$21,100
Visually similar · Automatic
Hublot
Classic Fusion King Gold Diamonds
38mm · Automatic$25,500
Visually similar · Automatic
Linde Werdelin
Oktopus Double Date 3DTP Carbon
44mm · Automatic$19,048
Visually similar · Automatic
Looks like this· 10

Visually-adjacent picks pulled by the image-similarity engine. Quality varies — sometimes a true twin, sometimes just a rhyme.

Pagani Design
PD-1888
40mm · Automatic$171
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Pagani Design
PD-1792 GMT
39mm · Automatic$137
Visually similar · Automatic
Pagani Design
PD-YS005
41mm · Automatic$171
Visually similar · Automatic
Sugess
Chrono Heritage S423
40mm · Manual$499
Looks nearly identical · Same size
Sugess
Ocean Star S421
40mm · Automatic$449
Visually similar · Automatic
Sugess
Seestern S430 Titanium Diver
40mm · Automatic$299
Visually similar · Automatic
Seestern
S471 Double Crown Diver
38mm · Automatic$179
Visually similar · Automatic
Seestern
Sub 300 V4
42mm · Automatic$10
Visually similar · Automatic
Ajwain Watches
Khaki edition
38mm · Manual$170
Same size · 95% less
Seestern
S424 Full Lume Pilot
38mm · Automatic$299
Automatic · Same size