Oris Oris X RedBar Limited Edition IIvsAigi Watches Arctic Tide

Owners widely praise the Oris X RedBar Limited Edition II as a "great looking piece," appreciating its red fumé dial and luminous indices. One owner notes the watch features an automatic Oris 733 movement and a 41-hour power reserve, with a 39mm case. Some in the community, however, wish for a 20mm lug width instead of 19mm and feel recent Oris releases lack distinctiveness beyond dial colors. Overall, owners and reviewers rate the Oris X RedBar Limited Edition II well for its attractive design and community-focused collaboration.

Owners report the Aigi Arctic Tide's dial markers catch the light similarly to Grand Seiko dials, and one user noted a preference for its movement over an alternative. Some owners consider the 40mm case size comfortable, while others found a 43mm variant chunky. One owner received their watch with a Miyota 9015 movement upgrade, and another experienced issues with lume and alignment on their initial unit, receiving a replacement. On balance, owners view the Aigi Arctic Tide as a decent value at its Kickstarter price, with good on-paper specifications, though concerns exist regarding the brand's newness and potential for it to be a catalogue watch.