Aquastar Benthos Heritage IIvsTudor Black Bay 58

lug2lug doesn't sell watches. Buy links open the brand's or seller's own site. Some links are affiliate links: lug2lug may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Disclosures

Measurements

Catalog photos are all shot at the same flattering size. These aren't: every case below shares one millimeter scale.

Aquastar Benthos Heritage II at true scale

Benthos Heritage II

Tudor Black Bay 58 at true scale

Black Bay 58

Diameter

40mm

39mm

Lug-to-Lug

44mm

n/a

Thickness

11.9mm

11.7mm

lowest

Water Resistance

300m

highest

200m

Movement

Sellita SW200-1

Tudor MT5400

Case

6 specs
Diameter
40mm
39mm
Thickness
11.9mm
11.7mm
Lug-to-Lug
44mm
n/a
Lug Width
n/a
n/a
Material
Stainless Steel
steel
Water Resistance
300m
200m

Crystal & Dial

1 specs
Dial Color
Black
n/a

Movement

2 specs
Caliber
Sellita SW200-1
Tudor MT5400
Power Reserve
n/a
0h
Keep your wishlist and collection together in the appExplore the app

Reviews

Synthesized for each watch independently from owner discussions, enthusiast forums, written reviews, and video reviewers.

Aquastar Benthos Heritage II

The Aquastar Benthos Heritage II is widely praised for its significantly improved wearability due to its 40mm case and reduced thickness, noted as 12mm by one source and 11.9mm by others, making it comfortable on smaller wrists. Reviewers and owners appreciate the scaling down of a classic design while retaining key elements, with the sapphire crystal and the manually operated helium release valve (HRV/HEV) being highlighted, the latter sometimes described as a "fidget aid." The watch is considered a fantastic value at its pre-order price of $1,190 on a rubber strap. Some owners miss the dial depth of earlier models, and the dual-crown design with the HRV is seen by some as a stylistic compromise. On balance, owners and reviewers rate the Aquastar Benthos Heritage II highly for its comfortable wearability and excellent value at the price point.

From video reviewers

The Aquastar Benthos Heritage II is praised for its modern execution of a vintage design. Reviewers did not cite any shared weaknesses.

Tudor Black Bay 58

The Tudor Bay 58 is widely praised for its superb wearing experience and rugged build quality, offering significant charm and modern construction. Owners note its substantial feel and a smooth clasp mechanism, though one reviewer flags the shield on the clasp as sharp. On balance, the Tudor Bay 58 is highly regarded for its excellent proportions and value at its price point.