Aquastar Model 60vsBremont S302

The Aquastar Model 60 is widely praised for its faithful vintage skin diver aesthetic, period-correct 37mm sizing, and excellent wearability. Reviewers and owners consistently highlight its charming recreation of a classic dive watch, with some noting its legibility underwater and refined bezel action. The watch is described as a straightforward and endearing dive watch that wears perfectly, making it a great daily wear for some. However, criticisms include simplistic finishing and a bi-directional bezel, which is noted as lacking the safety of a unidirectional one for actual diving. Some enthusiasts feel a flatter crystal lacks vintage charm, and the bezel appears slightly too broad compared to the original. Accuracy figures vary, with one reviewer testing at +3 seconds per day and another at approximately +6 seconds per day. The watch is priced competitively, with sources mentioning pre-order prices around $990 and a standard price of $1,290 or $1,390.

The Bremont S302 is widely praised for its balanced 40mm proportions and legible matte dial, featuring attractive tan accents. Reviewers note its satisfying bezel action and comfortable lug design, with one owner highlighting its scratch-resistant case as a true tool watch feature. However, some find the GMT bezel's integration a compromise and note potential alignment issues with the GMT hand and bezel that may require service. The watch is priced at £3,700 / over $4,000, with some considering its ETA movement high for the cost compared to competitors. On balance, owners and reviewers appreciate the Bremont S302 for its handsome, functional dive GMT design and wearability, despite some reservations about its GMT functionality and value proposition.