Charlie Paris Watches SULLY - Phase de Lune - Doré rosevsMassena LAB Habring² x Massena LAB Erwin LAB03

The consensus on the Charlie Paris Watches SULLY - Phase de Lune - Doré rose is thin, drawn from just two owner and community sources. One owner calls the reversed moon phase complication intentionally odd and admits it felt embarrassing to wear, though it works as advertised and carries a two-year warranty. Another commenter speaks only to the brand, describing Charlie Paris as well regarded in France and offering good value and decent quality, with no specific comment on this model's finish. Overall, the sparse feedback suggests the watch is seen as a reasonable-value piece from a respected brand, but the reversed moon phase is the defining trait that draws the most mixed reaction.

Owners and reviewers widely praise the Massena LAB Habring² x Massena LAB ERWIN LAB03 for its exceptional hand-finished bronze guilloché dial and the dead seconds complication. The watch is noted for its value at $9,450, with reviewers highlighting the high level of finishing, including the rose gold finished movement. Some collectors may prefer applied numerals over the painted Roman numerals. The 30mm case size is mentioned, with one reviewer noting the 38.5mm diameter might appear smaller than it is, and another suggesting the stepped bezel could make it seem thinner. The dials are produced with extensive hand labor, involving up to 25 steps in small series. Overall, owners and reviewers rate the Massena LAB Habring² x Massena LAB ERWIN LAB03 highly for its unique dial artistry and impressive movement finishing at its price point.