Garrick S5vsKnot Watches STS-38

The Garrick S5 Timepiece is praised for its 39mm case and 8mm slim height, offering a British take on neoclassical styling inspired by pocket watches. Its hand-guilloché dials are produced on traditional rose engine lathes, with extensive customization options available. The watch features an in-house manual-wind UT-GO5 caliber movement with a 60-hour power reserve. Overall, owners and reviewers rate the Garrick S5 highly for its distinctive hand-made guilloché dial and slender, wearable case.

Owners widely praise the Knot Watches STS-38's 38mm case size, finding it gorgeous and a go-to dress watch, with one owner noting the red lacquer dial with gold flecks is eye-catching and classy. The watch is priced between 45,000 and 50,000 JPY and comes with Japanese-made straps. Some owners find the 38mm case appears larger due to its all-dial design, while one owner finds the crown difficult to wind. One owner reports disappointment with the strap and engraving quality, and another experienced misaligned hands. Overall, owners rate the Knot Watches STS-38 highly for its attractive dial and comfortable wearability, despite some concerns regarding finishing and strap quality.