Hamilton American Classic Boulton MechanicalvsLorier Roosevelt

Owners widely praise the Hamilton American Classic Boulton Mechanical for its cool aesthetic and interesting company heritage. The manual-wind Hamilton H-50 movement is noted for its smooth winding action and hacking seconds, with the absence of a date complication being a welcomed feature. On balance, owners rate the Hamilton American Classic Boulton Mechanical highly for its distinctive design and user-friendly manual-wind movement.

Owners widely praise the Lorier Roosevelt's stunning dial, incredible case finishing, precise dial stamping, and clean printing. The manual-wind movement is noted for its buttery winding feel, and the brass construction is observed to develop a pleasing patina. One owner finds the 38mm case wears perfectly on a 7" wrist. However, the Miyota 9-series rotor is described as "insanely loud" by one owner, and the original $800 price point is considered steep by some, especially given competition and the lack of lume. On balance, owners value the Lorier Roosevelt for its beautiful dial and case finishing, with many finding it a great deal when purchased at a discount.