Islander Melville GMT with Black Hammer DialvsSan Martin BB GMT

Ref. islander-melville-gmt-with-black-hammer-dial-isl-255·MSRP $329

lug2lug doesn't sell watches. Buy links open the brand's or seller's own site. Some links are affiliate links: lug2lug may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Disclosures
Measurements
Catalog photos are all shot at the same flattering size. These aren't: every case below shares one millimeter scale.

Melville GMT with Black Hammer Dial

BB GMT
Diameter
40mm
39mm
Lug-to-Lug
40mm
n/a
Thickness
13mm
n/a
Water Resistance
100m
100m
MSRP
$329
$208
lowest
Movement
Seiko NH34
Seiko NH34
Case
4 specsPricing
1 specsReviews
Synthesized for each watch independently from owner discussions, enthusiast forums, written reviews, and video reviewers.
Owners widely praise the Islander Melville GMT with Black Hammer Dial #ISL-255 for its excellent quality and comfortable feel at its price point. One owner notes the lume is "pretty good," though hands and markers can blend with the dial over time, impacting legibility. Some find the 40mm case a bit thick due to the Seiko NH34 movement and would prefer a less textured dial. Overall, owners rate the Islander Melville GMT with Black Hammer Dial #ISL-255 highly for its impressive value and comfortable wearability.
Owners and forum reviewers respond warmly to the San Martin BB GMT's design, which one reviewer calls a handsome blend of the Black Bay Pro and Explorer II with a rugged, tool-like character that still dresses up. Owners praise the dial and logo in person, one calling the logo "fire," and a buyer at 260€ describes it as a steal for a 20 ATM watch with a sapphire AR-coated crystal, a Seiko GMT movement, and an on-the-fly adjustable clasp. The main criticism comes from one owner who finds the clasp big and unattractive, while another notes the design is an original of sorts rather than a pure homage. Overall, owners rate it well for the price, with its design and value doing most of the convincing.
Similar watches
Matched to the watches above on size, movement, style and price, microbrands first. Open any one to dig in.
Also compared
Comparisons nearby in the catalog: alternatives to the watches above paired against the matchup.









