Makydo 42vsLongines Legend Diver 42

Owners widely praise the Makydo 42 for its impressive finishing and solid feel at its price point, with the reliable Seiko NH35 movement noted as a strength. One owner confirmed the watch's asymmetrical case shape and found the leather strap elegant for dressier occasions. A negative customer service experience was reported by one user who received the wrong watch and did not get a correct replacement. Overall, owners rate the Makydo 42 highly for its finishing and value at the price point.

Owners widely praise the Longines Legend Diver 42 for its appealing retro design and excellent legibility, with reviewers highlighting its strong value proposition below $2,500 and practical quickset date. Some owners find the blue dial pops in the sun and appreciate its reliability for casual dives. However, several owners report disappointment after seeing the watch in person, finding it underwhelming and lacking dial depth. The original leather straps are noted to peel easily, and the clasp is a scratch magnet. Some owners find the 50mm lug-to-lug length and bracelet bulky on smaller wrists. One owner experienced the minute hand scratching the hour hand after fifteen years.