Melbourne Watch Company CarltonvsBrew Retrograph

lug2lug doesn't sell watches. Buy links open the brand's or seller's own site. Some links are affiliate links: lug2lug may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Disclosures

Measurements

Catalog photos are all shot at the same flattering size. These aren't: every case below shares one millimeter scale.

Melbourne Watch Company Carlton at true scale

Carlton

Brew Retrograph at true scale

Retrograph

Diameter

42mm

38mm

Lug-to-Lug

n/a

41.5mm

Thickness

11mm

10.4mm

lowest

Water Resistance

50m

50m

MSRP

$294

lowest

$375

Movement

Ronda 5021.D

Seiko VK64

Case

5 specs
Diameter
42mm
38mm
Thickness
11mm
10.4mm
Lug-to-Lug
n/a
41.5mm
Material
Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel 316L
Caseback
n/a
Stainless Steel 316L

Crystal & Dial

1 specs
Dial Color
Black
Cobalt Blue Sunburst

Movement

4 specs
Caliber
Ronda 5021.D
Seiko VK64
Type
Quartz
Meca-Quartz
Power Reserve
n/a
0h
Complications
None
Chronograph

Pricing

1 specs
MSRP
$294
$375
Keep your wishlist and collection together in the appExplore the app

Reviews

Synthesized for each watch independently from owner discussions, enthusiast forums, written reviews, and video reviewers.

Melbourne Watch Company Carlton

Owners widely praise the Melbourne Watch Company Carlton for its stunning rose gold color, immaculate dial, and excellent fit and finishing, with many appreciating its retro style and comfortable bracelet. The watch is considered good value at around $500 AUD, with its quartz movement offering lower cost and reduced servicing needs. Some owners note the 42mm case wears large, and one reviewer wished this characteristic was less pronounced on the rose gold variant. Overall, owners rate the Melbourne Watch Company Carlton highly for its aesthetic appeal and perceived quality at the price point.

Brew Retrograph

The Brew Retrograph is widely praised for its unique design and comfortable wearability, with owners highlighting its well-finished rectangular case featuring alternating polishing and brushing, and its sunburst dials. The Seiko VK64 meca-quartz movement is considered solid and appropriate for the price, offering an instantaneous chronograph reset and quartz accuracy, though the date change is not instant and some units may have a misaligned chronograph hand. Owners note the 38mm case size is versatile and comfortable, suitable for formal occasions and daily wear, and appreciate the sapphire crystal. However, some sources mention poor lume and the strap could benefit from design and material improvements. Overall, owners rate the Brew Retrograph highly for its distinctive aesthetic and comfortable 38mm wearability at an accessible price point.

Similar watches

Matched to the watches above on size, movement, style and price, microbrands first. Open any one to dig in.

DiscussionNot started

Also compared

Comparisons nearby in the catalog: alternatives to the watches above paired against the matchup.