Melbourne Watch Company CarltonvsYema Rallygraf Meca-Quartz II

lug2lug doesn't sell watches. Buy links open the brand's or seller's own site. Some links are affiliate links: lug2lug may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Disclosures

Measurements

Catalog photos are all shot at the same flattering size. These aren't: every case below shares one millimeter scale.

Melbourne Watch Company Carlton at true scale

Carlton

Yema Rallygraf Meca-Quartz II at true scale

Rallygraf Meca-Quartz II

Diameter

42mm

40mm

Thickness

11mm

11mm

Water Resistance

50m

50m

MSRP

$294

lowest

$450

Movement

Ronda 5021.D

Quartz

Case

3 specs
Diameter
42mm
40mm
Lug Width
22mm
20mm
Material
Stainless Steel
316L Stainless Steel

Crystal & Dial

1 specs
Dial Color
Black
Panda

Movement

2 specs
Caliber
Ronda 5021.D
n/a
Power Reserve
n/a
0h

Pricing

1 specs
MSRP
$294
$450
Keep your wishlist and collection together in the appExplore the app

Reviews

Synthesized for each watch independently from owner discussions, enthusiast forums, written reviews, and video reviewers.

Melbourne Watch Company Carlton

Owners widely praise the Melbourne Watch Company Carlton for its stunning rose gold color, immaculate dial, and excellent fit and finishing, with many appreciating its retro style and comfortable bracelet. The watch is considered good value at around $500 AUD, with its quartz movement offering lower cost and reduced servicing needs. Some owners note the 42mm case wears large, and one reviewer wished this characteristic was less pronounced on the rose gold variant. Overall, owners rate the Melbourne Watch Company Carlton highly for its aesthetic appeal and perceived quality at the price point.

Yema Rallygraf Meca-Quartz II

Owners widely praise the Yema Rallygraf Meca-Quartz II for its cool retro 70s vibe and car dashboard styling, with its faithful reissue of a small, thin vintage design and tactile pushers noted as strengths, especially considering its price point. The Milanese strap is described as top-notch, and the watch has a substantial, weighty feel that wears smaller than expected, with well-aligned indices and no play in the movement when setting the time. However, some find the meca-quartz ticking not very smooth, the left subdial a "useless" 24h indicator, and the watch overpriced compared to similar models. Owners are split on Yema's quality control, with some reporting no issues and others experiencing or hearing about crooked indices, dial rotation when pushers are depressed or time is set, and a fixed strap loop that limits adjustment. Yema's customer service and communication regarding shipping and strap availability are also criticized by some owners.

From video reviewers

The watch's vintage-inspired design and value at its price point are consistently praised. The meca-quartz movement is mentioned as a feature by multiple reviewers.