Out of Order CasanovavsSan Martin BB58

lug2lug doesn't sell watches. Buy links open the brand's or seller's own site. Some links are affiliate links: lug2lug may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Disclosures
Measurements
Catalog photos are all shot at the same flattering size. These aren't: every case below shares one millimeter scale.

Casanova

BB58
Diameter
38mm
40mm
Lug-to-Lug
46mm
n/a
Thickness
12.2mm
n/a
Water Resistance
100m
200m
highest
Power Reserve
41h
n/a
MSRP
n/a
$274
Movement
Seiko NH35
Seiko NH35
Case
5 specsCrystal & Dial
2 specsMovement
1 specsPricing
1 specsReviews
Synthesized for each watch independently from owner discussions, enthusiast forums, written reviews, and video reviewers.
Owners widely appreciate the Out of Order Casanova's unique "damaged in Italy" aesthetic and its blend with natural settings, though some find the design obnoxious or question the "Made in Italy" claim. The watch features a mother-of-pearl dial and a Seiko NH35 automatic movement, with one reviewer noting accuracy within ±8 seconds per day. Its 38mm case and 12.25mm thickness are described as comfortable for a range of wrists, though one owner found it heavier than expected. Price is a point of contention, with one commenter calling it a rip-off while a reviewer notes its attractive price point for an automatic diver. Overall, owners rate the Out of Order Casanova highly for its distinctive design and comfortable wearability at its price point.
Owners widely regard the San Martin BB58 as a strong value, with one calling the v2 "basically as close as you can get without paying Tudor prices" and another saying they have not seen a $1k watch that can touch it. Its on-the-fly micro-adjust clasp draws the most praise: one forum reviewer finds it very nice and functional, and owners single it out as a high-quality addition in the v2. One owner describes the watch as gorgeous yet masculine and calls San Martin's quality fantastic for the price. The main reservation comes from one owner who would only buy it if the riveted links were dropped and the logo changed. Overall, owners rate the San Martin BB58 highly as a Tudor-style homage, with the clasp and finishing at this price the biggest reasons.
Similar watches
Matched to the watches above on size, movement, style and price, microbrands first. Open any one to dig in.
Also compared
Comparisons nearby in the catalog: alternatives to the watches above paired against the matchup.











