Pagani Design PD-1719vsSan Martin BB58 PT5000 Automatic

lug2lug doesn't sell watches. Buy links open the brand's or seller's own site. Some links are affiliate links: lug2lug may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Disclosures

Measurements

Catalog photos are all shot at the same flattering size. These aren't: every case below shares one millimeter scale.

Pagani Design PD-1719 at true scale

PD-1719

San Martin BB58 PT5000 Automatic at true scale

BB58 PT5000 Automatic

Diameter

42.5mm

40mm

Thickness

14mm

n/a

Water Resistance

300m

highest

200m

Power Reserve

42h

n/a

MSRP

$185

lowest

$309

Movement

Automatic

PT5000

Case

4 specs
Diameter
42.5mm
40mm
Thickness
14mm
n/a
Lug Width
20mm
n/a
Water Resistance
300m
200m

Crystal & Dial

2 specs
AR Coating
Yes
n/a
Dial Color
n/a
n/a

Movement

2 specs
Caliber
n/a
PT5000
Power Reserve
42h
0h

Pricing

1 specs
MSRP
$185
$309
Keep your wishlist and collection together in the appExplore the app

Reviews

Synthesized for each watch independently from owner discussions, enthusiast forums, written reviews, and video reviewers.

Pagani Design PD-1719

Owners express disappointment with the Pagani Design PD-1719, citing poor lume and QC issues like misaligned hands and a bezel with play. Some commenters found the hands resembled chess pieces or "parsnips" rather than the intended design. Applied indices are appreciated, and the dial and bracelet are generally liked. On balance, owners rate the Pagani Design PD-1719 poorly due to QC issues and perceived poor value compared to competitors.

From video reviewers

The 300m water resistance is a notable strength. The lume is a drawback.

San Martin BB58 PT5000 Automatic

Owners widely praise the San Martin BB58 PT5000 Automatic SN008 for its excellent finishing, impressive value, and overall build quality, with some stating the brand "really got this right." The PT5000 movement is generally considered reliable, comparable to an ETA 2824, and arrives with specific accuracy statistics. However, opinions differ on the rose gold indices and silver bezel accents, with some finding them undesirable, and a few owners criticize the sharp edges of the bezel and the applied logo as too blingy. One owner reported the PT5000 movement failed after five months, while another noted the 40mm case size felt small for their wrist, though another source considered it comparable to the BB58 Monochrome. Overall, owners rate the San Martin BB58 PT5000 Automatic SN008 highly for its exceptional build quality and value.