Squale Super-SqualevsTudor Black Bay 58

Owners widely praise the Squale Super-Squale for its comfortable 38mm case, vintage skin diver aesthetic, and outstanding build quality for the price, with many highlighting the beads-of-rice bracelet as a standout feature and finding it a great value "go anywhere, do anything" watch. Some owners note the stock strap is not ideal and consider alternative strap options, while one enthusiast finds the 38mm case with 18mm lug width wears small. Accuracy of the Sellita SW200-1 movement is reported as ±7–20 seconds per day, which is considered not impressive by today's standards, though adequate for reliability and serviceability. Overall, owners rate the Squale Super-Squale highly for its vintage charm, comfortable wearability, and excellent value.

The Tudor Bay 58 is widely praised for its superb wearing experience and rugged build quality, offering significant charm and modern construction. Owners note its substantial feel and a smooth clasp mechanism, though one reviewer flags the shield on the clasp as sharp. On balance, the Tudor Bay 58 is highly regarded for its excellent proportions and value at its price point.