Astor + Banks AB1405vsHamilton American Classic Spirit of Liberty Auto

Owners widely praise the Astor + Banks AB1405 for its solid finishing and impressive bracelet, with one owner noting it is extremely well-regulated and accurate. The manual-wind movement is a point of discussion, with some finding it a great value for a mechanical watch. One reviewer flagged legibility issues with the fully lumed dial and a recessed date display. Overall, owners rate the Astor + Banks AB1405 highly for its build quality and value.

Owners widely praise the Hamilton American Classic Spirit of Liberty Auto for its elegant design, quality finishing, and refined yet bold presence, with multiple sources highlighting its attractive, simple, and classical dial layout featuring applied indices. Some owners find the 42mm case size and 12mm thickness ideal for wearability, while others note the bracelet hinders wearability and the watch's dressier style limits versatility. The H-10 automatic movement is noted for its 80-hour power reserve, though one owner reported accuracy of +10 seconds per day. Legibility can be an issue due to thin hands on a reflective dial, and the laser-engraved quote on the leather strap is a point of contention for some. Overall, owners and reviewers consider the Hamilton American Classic Spirit of Liberty Auto a stylish and affordable watch offering excellent value for its craftsmanship.