IWC Schaffhausen Iw3565 Portofino AutomaticvsSeagull Ultra-thin Moon Phase Dress 38mm

Owners widely praise the IWC Schaffhausen Iw3565 Portofino Automatic for its clean, classic dress watch aesthetics and a 40mm dial size that suits smaller wrists. The watch is noted for its simple elegance and appealing color, with one owner reporting excellent timekeeping. However, some owners question its value, citing the use of an external movement and a price tag they find high for the caliber, leading to concerns about resale value compared to watches with in-house movements. One owner reported a significant repair time after dropping their watch. Overall, owners rate the IWC Schaffhausen Iw3565 Portofino Automatic highly for its sophisticated design and wearability on various wrists, though value perception varies due to its movement and price point.

Owners widely praise the Seagull Ultra-thin Moon Phase Dress Watch 38mm for its elegance and value, with one owner calling it a favorite dress watch and another finding it gorgeous for its moon phase complication under $150. The 38mm case size is considered by some to be a bit small for larger wrists, though others prefer this standard size. Service and maintenance are noted as significant downsides. Overall, owners rate the Seagull Ultra-thin Moon Phase Dress Watch 38mm highly for its attractive dial and moon phase complication at an accessible price point.