Rolex Submariner DatevsTudor Black Bay 58
lug2lug doesn't sell watches. Buy links open the brand's or seller's own site. Some links are affiliate links: lug2lug may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Disclosures
Measurements
Catalog photos are all shot at the same flattering size. These aren't: every case below shares one millimeter scale.

Submariner Date

Black Bay 58
Diameter
41mm
39mm
Thickness
n/a
11.7mm
Water Resistance
300m
highest
200m
Power Reserve
70h
n/a
MSRP
$50,900
n/a
Movement
3235
Tudor MT5400
Case
8 specsCrystal & Dial
4 specsMovement
7 specsPricing
1 specsReviews
Synthesized for each watch independently from owner discussions, enthusiast forums, written reviews, and video reviewers.
Owners widely prefer the no-date Submariner for its cleaner dial symmetry and classic aesthetic, with some finding the date function and cyclops an unnecessary clutter. Others, however, find the date complication essential for daily utility and appreciate the cyclops as a key Rolex characteristic. The Rolex Submariner Date is described as a versatile, lifelong watch that holds its value well. Overall, owners are split on the Rolex Submariner Date, with a preference for the no-date version due to its cleaner symmetry and historical aesthetic, while others value the date functionality.
The Tudor Bay 58 is widely praised for its superb wearing experience and rugged build quality, offering significant charm and modern construction. Owners note its substantial feel and a smooth clasp mechanism, though one reviewer flags the shield on the clasp as sharp. On balance, the Tudor Bay 58 is highly regarded for its excellent proportions and value at its price point.
Similar watches
Matched to the watches above on size, movement, style and price, microbrands first. Open any one to dig in.
Also compared
Comparisons nearby in the catalog: alternatives to the watches above paired against the matchup.







