Rolex GMT-Master IIvsTudor Black Bay 58 GMT

lug2lug doesn't sell watches. Buy links open the brand's or seller's own site. Some links are affiliate links: lug2lug may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Disclosures

Measurements

Catalog photos are all shot at the same flattering size. These aren't: every case below shares one millimeter scale.

Rolex GMT-Master II at true scale

GMT-Master II

Tudor Black Bay 58 GMT at true scale

Black Bay 58 GMT

Diameter

40mm

39mm

Thickness

n/a

12.8mm

Water Resistance

100m

200m

highest

Power Reserve

70h

n/a

MSRP

$53,100

n/a

Movement

3285

Tudor MT5450

Case

7 specs
Diameter
40mm
39mm
Thickness
n/a
12.8mm
Lug Width
n/a
20mm
Material
Oystersteel
steel
Finish
18 kt Everose gold
n/a
Water Resistance
100m
200m
Caseback
Monobloc middle case, screw-down case back and winding crown
n/a

Crystal & Dial

4 specs
Crystal Shape
Flat
n/a
Dial Color
Black
n/a
Indices
Index
n/a
Lume
Chromalight
None

Movement

7 specs
Caliber
3285
Tudor MT5450
Beat Rate
28,800 vph
0 vph
Power Reserve
70h
0h
Jewels
34
0
Hacking
Yes
No
Hand-winding
Yes
No
Complications
GMT, Date
None

Pricing

1 specs
MSRP
$53,100
n/a
Keep your wishlist and collection together in the appExplore the app

Reviews

Synthesized for each watch independently from owner discussions, enthusiast forums, written reviews, and video reviewers.

Rolex GMT-Master II

Owners widely praise the Rolex GMT-Master II for its exceptional finishing on the Oystersteel case and bracelet, the legibility of its dial with excellent lume, and the scratch-resistance of its ceramic bezel. Many owners find it a perfect balance between sport and dress, appreciating the GMT function for travel and citing specific configurations like the "Batman" (BLNR) and "Pepsi" (BLRO) as favorites for their versatility and color schemes. The Jubilee bracelet is frequently lauded as comfortable and fantastic, with some preferring it over the Oyster. However, some owners note the bidirectional bezel lacks satisfying clicks, and one reviewer found the green GMT hand and text difficult to read. The Rolex GMT-Master II is also noted for being difficult to acquire at retail, with long wait times for popular steel models.

From video reviewers

The GMT-Master II "Root Beer" features a distinctive black and brown Cerachrom bezel and GMT complication. Reviewers did not agree on any weaknesses.

Tudor Black Bay 58 GMT

The Tudor Black Bay 58 GMT is praised for its functional, proportional, and ergonomic design, wearing identically to the standard Black Bay 58. Owners highlight the gilt dial aesthetics and improved case proportions, noting a 12.8mm height. Some find the gilt accents and black/burgundy bezel insert divisive, while others appreciate the new METAS-certified movement with 15,000 Gauss resistance, though a slight reduction in power reserve to 65 hours is noted. Overall, owners rate the Tudor Black Bay 58 GMT highly for its comfortable wearability and classic gilt dial aesthetics.

From video reviewers

The 39mm case size is a significant strength for comfortable daily wear. Concerns exist regarding the 39mm case size potentially impacting GMT legibility.